Holly Andersen of Simon Fraser University will talk on the topic of "Causation as transfer of conserved quantities is not itself conserved".
The conserved quantity/mark transmission account of Salmon (1998) has suffered from a series of criticisms and receives little current consideration. Some of these criticisms are based on misunderstandings of his view, and some are legitimate, but can be addressed with a clarification or minor extension of his original account. Andersen will focus on an obscure illustration he uses of three different kinds of interactions - X, Y, and lambda - to draw out a consequence of his view that has vast consequences for what causation is like. She will show how his causal nexus can be treated as a series of edges and nodes, yielding a useful graphical representation. From there, she will demonstrate how the conserved quantity account requires that causation is not itself a conserved quantity. Put another way, causation as a conserved quantity is not meta-conserved. She will then sketch out how this underappreciated insight of Salmon's about different kinds of interactions is actually a kind of token-causation correlate of D separation for variable causation. This connection between the graphical causal nexus and D separation of graphs of causal structure among variables is a key step towards bringing a metaphysical foundation up underneath the methodological of interventionism.
Free and open to the public.
Friday, March 23, 2018 at 4:15pm to 6:15pm
Eliot Hall, 207
3203 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard, Portland, Oregon 97202-8199
Reed Community Members
If you are a member of the Reed community, you MUST LOG IN to see events that are open ONLY to the Reed community. Log in with your Reed ID (your Kerberos account information). If you don’t remember your account username or password, go to reed.edu/cis/help/kerberos.html.Log in with Reed ID